Finger Hands https://www.amazon.com/Accoutrements-Five-Rubber-Finger-Hands/dp/B00OAC9BUO
Irish Accent Gum https://www.amazon.com/Blue-Q-FS1003-Instant-Accent/dp/B008YGNCTI/
Dinosaur Taco Holder https://www.amazon.com/KidsFunwares-TriceraTACO-Taco-Holder-Prehistoric/dp/B01LZNTN8S/
Nicholas Cage Pillow Cover https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07WNW7SHG/
Depends on what podcasts she likes, but lots of them are doing fundraisers around this time with rewards (like Radiotopia is giving everyone who donates any amount of money cute watercolor stickers of every show's logo)
If you're looking for something white elephant-y, there's a triceratops taco holder, or this necklacewith a skeleton