Now THAT's something that I had never thought of !! It led me down a rabbit hole but by searching "ivory correction tape" and "cream correction tape", here is what I was able to find !

https://www.tokyopenshop.com/correction-products-c-1/whiper-cream-correction-tape-p-3306.html

https://www.amazon.com/HUIHE-Correction-Non-Refillable-Students-Office/dp/B07FKZLZ7H

https://www.amazon.com/Corrective-Correction-Refillable-Administration-Crafting/dp/B08X29VKSR/

(Note, I haven't used any of these, I am using stupid white correction tape but now I look at it differently and I want cream colored tape ! Thank you not for making me realize I had this first world problem haha!)