I got this one back in May and it's been perfect since. Daily use in and out of pocket, though never dropped. The soft-touch feels very high quality and hasn't peeled for me, contrary to reviews.

It has a similar little piece of plastic over the volume rocker so I felt it was relevant.

Bleep bloop.

i bought the Pallete and the Atmosphere and i like the atmosphere a lot better, i feel like it gives it more protection around the corners where the pallete felt like it wasnt protecting to well there. I've dropped my phone 3 times since putting it on and no problems at all, i would highly recommend the atmosphere