So far nothing below a 4 star haha
(Sorry about potato quality, only had Moto G on hand)
Got this from Amazon the same day I got my phone, love the case. Its 2 Pieces, the phone kinda locks into the front cover, and the and the back shell goes around that. It's a rubber exterior but not the very resistant rubber like the Defender series from Otterbox so it easily goes in and out of your pocket.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00JW7APWU/ref=oh_details_o01_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
I'm using the Supcase Unicorn Beetle. It might be bulkier than what you are looking for but I'm clumsy so I wanted armor plating. My only problem is the screen protector is too reflective. It's fine for most things but when I'm looking at something dark, like a night scene in a movie, all I can see is my ugly face.