After doing a lot of thinking and browsing I settled on buying this particular one. Edit: the link seems to be taking it to a different product. I checked my order history and it's the right link. I'm going to leave it up for now in hopes it's just a glitch.

So far the connection is great, charging works fine and honestly it seats a little bit easier on this one. It doesn't feel feel cheap, but it doesn't have the weight of the OEM puck because it's a plastic build.

Definitely worth the $11.99 I paid to have this little guy on the go in my pocket.