Thanks to everyone's recommendations, I have a few turntables to look at! Here's what I'm considering so far.
Audio-Technica At-LP60X-BW I really like the brown color.
Audio-Technica LP60X-BT [Standard Color] or Audio-Technica LP60X-BT [UO; White]
Gemini UO Exclusive TT-1000BT I didn't see this one recommended, but it looks really cool, I'm going to check reviews on it.
Audio-Technica LP120XUSB or the Bluetooth version Audio-Technica ATLP120XBT
And, maybe if I find a decently priced Technics MK 1700 II I might give that a look too. Most of these are fully or semi automatic except for the LP120X which is admittedly very lovely. I have a lot of thinking to do, so thanks to everyone who's given me advice!