No it wasn't actually - it was a cross-post from ThinkGeek.com and had the exact same description on both sites (though on ThinkGeek it had all models on the same page with a drop-down selector), just that Amazon had separate pages for each of the 3 case models.

And from some of the comments, you can hardly respect their arguments:

"It does NOT FIT the ipod touch 4! I bought it for an ipod touch 4, not an iphone, not a 5, not anything else. I have an ipod touch 4. This case is much too big, probably fits an iPHONE."

"Got it for a gift. The case is too long and narrow. Not sure which device it really goes to."

"This case does not fit the iPod touch that I bought. I bought them together on Amazon, so I expected them to match. Wasted $20"

"The Thinkgeek site stated they had 4 or 5 for this and it was ONLY for 5. Very disappointed on Christmas morning to discover that and there is NOTHING stated on the box as to which iTouch it is for. For a 5 this would be fine, but totally misleading."

"I too purchased this for ipod touch and it does not fit. Read the fine print that it only fits ipod touch 5th generation. Boo and will never order here again"

"Boo and will never order here again" Really? Someone will never order from Amazon again because they couldn't figure out what they were buying? Understandably it didn't have the words "5th Generation Only" in bold letters in the title, but some of these people apparently don't know that there are different models of iPods and iPhones.