any item that is cookie-related (duh! hehe) I almost bought some of these at the store earlier...
a stamp plate with flowers on it - I love the dandelions!
any polish that I've used for a previous manicure of mine Revlon Whimsical. You need to post more manis! :P
nail stickers or decals that include hearts - hearts AND leopard print!
a neon polish 'Cause this polish is really bright :)
a nail tool orange sticks!
a China Glaze or Essie polish that I own Looks like it was recently purchased off of your wishlist, at least :)
a Hello Kitty item Nails AND Hello Kitty!
any polish that starts with "S" (not the brand, but the polish name) Smooth Sailing by Essie!
a polish that costs $5 or less, including shipping $2.99 + $2 shipping at the time I'm writing this :)
a holo polish <3 Color Club holos
a limited edition polish Since I just saw a post earlier today looking for this polish...
a polish that costs more than $10, but less than $15 (incl. shipping) KB Shimmer :)
a seasonal polish (i.e. Holiday collection, summer collection, etc.) Essie summer!
a polish that I have gifted someone else with (through contest or giveaway; either one counts) For your cake day
something glittery that is NOT nail polish-related ... I don't quite know what to make of that handle
the polish that has been on any PG mod's Amazon wishlist the longest (choose any mod, just tell me which so I can verify. Mods, if you're playing, choose another mod that's not you!) for /u/DarthVaderette
any item with a bow on it Cupid's Bow! Probably not the type you were intending, but it's still a bow ;-)
any item with cheetah pattern on it A horse fly mask?
any birthday-related item A birthday cake dog toy!
Happy (almost) birthday! This was fun! Thanks for hosting :)
Oops, edited to add: "You can steal cookies on your birthday" I'd rather just give you cookies, though :)