It's your record player. The first $60 Bosley player I got did the same goddamn thing.
Invest in an Audio-Technica. It's around $90-99 and it's the best you can get for the value.
I have a couple questions about vinyls. I currently don't have any so I'm new to all this vinyl stuff. However, I want to start collecting them from my favorite bands. Do you buy them all online? Also, what do you use to play them? A quick amazon search shows me I should probably buy this turntable.
I have the same setup. On amazon the audio technic a turntable is a great replacement for the original. I removed mine and replace it with one of these turntable
I don't have Alive 2007 on vinyl, but I do have Discovery and RAM. Holy shit they sound so good. I'd heard RAM a thousand times digitally on my m50x before getting the record, and it was a whole new experience.
If you want a better turntable, this is what I have. Sounds very good even through just good-tier receiver and speakers.