I hope you are car camping because good luck carrying any of those coleman's while backpacking. The second one you linked is light enough if you split it with a partner. Also I've never once had a dry night in a coleman tent. They all have poor rain-flys and poor construction in everyone that I have tried and seen. You'll notice the rain-fly set up on all those tents does not cover the entire tent. I'd rather spend the extra money for lighter weight and durability in storms.

my backpacking tent note I split the weight with my husband and the rainfly covers the entire tent. 4lbs/$130/2person small tent (large enough for one person plus gear or two people willing to snuggle with gear).

my car camping tent I love this tent. It has a full rainfly and attachable vestibules and the "garage" (I use the garage). 2 doors, 20lbs, $440, (roomy enough for a couple people plus gear technically a 6p tent)

I've been happy with my Kelty Grand Mesa 2, which Amazon has for $120. Good design, reasonable quality, fairly lightweight, very good price/performance.