Not silly--I always wonder why this doesn't come up on the boards more often. Do males/people that don't wear makeup get KC more than females? Not to be gender normative but I wonder.
Anyways, I like this eyeliner:
Also, I don't wear mascara a lot because it's too much of a pain, but I find Blinc mascara works pretty well as long as you don't mind that it's a "tube" mascara and you have to pull the tubes off with water at the end of the night.