They both suck for IQ... Like noticeably so even over the basic kit lens. If you are just going to use it for snapshots that is one thing, and in that case i would go with https://www.amazon.com/Tamron-18-400mm-3-5-6-3-Digital-Warranty/dp/B072YT9KXW 18-400. If you are going to kill your IQ might as well get 400mm out of it