I think I'm going to order that one.

Are you saying that b/c of the 2.5D edges, something like this wouldn't work? (I'm looking at the third picture from the bottom and the second note in the description about curved edges)

I really wish there was a unanimously good option or two, but it seems like we'll just have to hold out hope for that. For now it's worth the imperfections to me for the added protection compared to using a plastic one or going naked.

Are you using this one with a case?