One of mine loved a frisbee. She would fold it in half, grab the middle, shake it until it flew up then go fetch it herself! https://smile.amazon.com/Petmate-Booda-Tail-Spin-Floating-Available/dp/B000W4L54O/ref=sr_1_6?crid=1Y3JCTF7W0YUW&keywords=soft+dog+frisbee&qid=1567266535&s=gateway&sprefix=soft+dog+frisbee%2Caps%2C167&sr=8-6